The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit has released its full letter explaining its decision to rule in Grayscale’s favor in its lawsuit with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
The decisive 3-0 victory for the company is based on the SEC’s “unreasonable” justification for favoring futures ETFs over spot products, and its inability to provide evidence for its claims.
Grayscale’s Victory Explained
Per the court’s decision on Tuesday, the SEC “failed to adequately explain why it
approved the listing of two bitcoin futures ETPs but not Grayscale’s proposed bitcoin ETP.”
Filed last year, Grayscale’s lawsuit against the SEC accused the agency of “arbitrary and capricious treatment” in denying the Bitcoin fund’s conversion into a Bitcoin spot ETF, despite previously approving multiple futures ETF of a similar nature.
Grayscale specifically pointed to the Teucrium and Valkyrie Bitcoin ETPs, which hold identical surveillance-sharing agreements (SSAs) with CME Bitcoin futures as what Grayscale proposed for its own product.
Therefore, the legal debate surrounded whether a market for Bitcoin futures could be used to adequately detect fraud in the spot market, upon which Grayscale’s ETF would be based.
According to the court, Grayscale won that debate.
“Grayscale presented uncontested evidence that there is a 99.9 percent correlation between bitcoin’s spot market and CME futures contract prices,” the court said. “Because the spot and futures markets for bitcoin are highly related, it stands to reason that manipulation in either market will affect the price of bitcoin futures.”
The SEC’s Insufficient Arguments
The SEC attempted to argue that CME Bitcoin Futures did not meet the threshold for a “market of significant size.”
This threshold has two prongs: that a market manipulator would need to trade on the market to manipulate the ETF, and that the proposed ETF would not be the “predominant influence on prices in [the surveilled] market.”
While the SEC originally found that Grayscale had failed both prongs, the court deemed the commission to have applied both prongs “unreasonably.” In particular, the agency’s argument that the correlation between Bitcoin’s spot and futures markets does not “provide evidence of the causal economic relationship of interest,” was found to be “insufficient.”
“The Commission’s unexplained discounting of the obvious financial and mathematical relationship between the spot and futures markets falls short of the standard for reasoned decisionmaking,” the court said.
The SEC has now been ordered to reconsider Grayscale’s ETF application. Analysts believe the order boosts the odds of a Bitcoin spot ETF being approved in the U.S.
Crypto markets surged after the ruling on Tuesday, as did the price of GBTC stock. Based on current prices, the fund’s discount against its underlying BTC has now narrowed to less than 20%.
Binance Free $100 (Exclusive): Use this link to register and receive $100 free and 10% off fees on Binance Futures first month (terms).
PrimeXBT Special Offer: Use this link to register & enter CRYPTOPOTATO50 code to receive up to $7,000 on your deposits.