As the story goes with most trends in our line of work, one sunny afternoon, a shoe almost immediately emerged as the quintessential footwear choice. In this case, the shoe in question was the Fisherman sandals. Their rise to prominence was swift, becoming a staple for those seeking an easy-to-style option when the temperature rises. Spotting them on the streets had become somewhat of a game and it was one of the sure signs that summer had officially begun. However, as with any trend, their ubiquity led to questions about their enduring appeal. With summer fast approaching and the Fisherman sandal market so saturated, one couldn’t help but wonder: Are they still in style?
We say yes. Despite the initial saturation, these classic strappy sandals have managed to maintain their place in the fashion scene, albeit with a hint of controversy. Influencers and celebrities alike continue to embrace them, showcasing innovative ways to style these versatile shoes. From Monikh Dale and Lois Sterling pairing The Row Fisherman sandals with flowy dresses, which offer a more bohemian vibe, to others opting to pair them with tailored trousers and jeans—there’s no shortage of inspiration. Yet, for some, Fisherman Sandals remain a polarising choice, criticised for their chunky silhouette and perceived lack of sophistication.
They’ve even divided the Who What Wear UK office. Acting affiliates editor, Florrie Alexander, is a staunch advocate, proclaiming, “I love how Fisherman Sandals simply add a laid-back, summer-ready vibe to any outfit. Plus, they’re incredibly comfortable for all-day wear.” Her sentiment resonates with a few others in the office who share her enthusiasm for the trend. Rebecca Rhys-Evans, senior fashion & beauty editor, branded content is a cult sandal gal and she can’t deny the appeal of the Fishermans “As someone that loves a thong kitten heel, I tried a pair of fisherman’s for a story at Who What Wear UK and have since swapped them for sneakers in summer as they are so comfortable”
I for one, however, was a little hesitant to warm up to the shoe. As a classic dresser, I found the sandals a little too chunky and casual for my style. The wide strapped design and often too-thick sole clashes with my preference for sleek and refined pieces. Although, I can’t deny the way they elevated a recent outfit of mine, which consisted of a black maxi T-shirt dress and tote bag—so they may just win me over yet.
Love them or loathe them, Fisherman Sandals show no signs of disappearing. Their enduring popularity speaks to their timeless appeal and adaptability. So, whether you’re a devoted fan like Florrie or a former skeptic like myself, the debate rages on: Are Fisherman Sandals done? What’s your take? We think they’ll always have a place in our footwear collection. Keep scrolling for the styles that team Who What Wear UK wholeheartedly recommend.
Shop Our Favourite Fisherman Sandals:
THE ROW
Fisherman Woven Textured-Leather Sandals
These are just a classic—and the ones that won me over.
JW ANDERSON
Fisherman Embossed Leather Sandals
We love a white pair of sandals to break up an all black look.
ROGER VIVIER
Viv Rangers Fisherman Patent-Leather and Grosgrain Sandals
i love the large buckle detail on this pair.
White Stuff
Leather Ankle Strap Fisherman Sandals
For the ones that want a more warm weather appropriate colour than black.
ZARA
Flat Leather Cage Sandals
I love how flat the soles are on this pair.
mango
Leather Jelly Shoes
A few Who What Wear editors stand by these sandals because they are so comfortable.
Prada
Logo Fisherman Sandals
I mean, is there a pair of shoes Prada doesn’t ever nail?
Miu Miu
Fisherman Platform Sandals
The bigger the platform, the better is what we say.
mango
Leather Jelly Shoes
A block heeled version, yes please!
LEMAIRE
Fisherman Leather Sandals
If square toe flats and Fishermans had a baby it would be these sandals from Lemaire.
The mid block heel really won me over.
Maeve
Maeve Wide-Banded Leather Fisherman Sandals
I can see these worn with a cute white cotton dress this summer.
ANCIENT GREEK SANDALS
Homeria Leather Fisherman Sandals
Ancient Greek Sandals is my go-to holiday footwear brand of choice, so I was very happy when I saw this iteration of sandals.
The Row
Pablo Suede Fisherman Sandals
You can never have enough suede shoes for the warmer months—so what’s a little indulgence curtesy of The Row?
Pilcro
Pilcro Flatform Leather Fisherman Sandals